Web Analytics Tools
Overview
This comprehensive guide compares user analytics platforms covering features, privacy, usability, and insights to help you choose the right tool for marketing, product, or UX needs.
Analytics Tools Overview
Google Analytics 4
Industry standard with Google ecosystem integration, predictive metrics, and cross-platform tracking.
Key Links:
Strengths
Completely free to use (unless GA360)
Industry standard in web analytics
Tight Google ecosystem integration (Ads, BigQuery, Firebase, Looker Studio)
Predictive metrics and AI-driven insights
Massive community support, documentation, and tutorials
Weaknesses
Data sampling and thresholds in free version
Privacy concerns (no direct data ownership, Google-hosted)
Complex UI with a steep learning curve
Strong dependency on Google's stack
Requires cookie consent banners for compliance
PostHog
Product analytics and experimentation platform with session replay, feature flags, and A/B testing.
Key Link: Analytics Platform
Strengths
Generous free tier (1M events/month)
All-in-one product analytics suite
MIT licensed (fully open source)
Self-hosting option available
A/B testing and feature flags included
Weaknesses
Complex initial setup
Resource intensive for self-hosting
Usage-based pricing scales quickly
Technical learning curve
Can get expensive at high volumes
Plausible
Lightweight, privacy-focused analytics with minimal overhead and simple dashboards.
Key Link: Analytics Platform
Strengths
AGPL open source (self-host free)
Ultra lightweight (<1KB script)
Cookieless privacy by design
Very affordable ($9-19/mo cloud)
Dead simple to use
Weaknesses
Limited product analytics
No session replay or heatmaps
Few integrations
Basic web analytics only
No user-level tracking
Microsoft Clarity
Free behavior visualization tool with heatmaps, session recordings, and frustration signals.
Key Link: Analytics Platform
Strengths
Completely free forever (no limits)
MIT licensed core library
Excellent UX insights
Automatic heatmaps and recordings
No traffic or feature limits
Weaknesses
Not a full analytics platform
Microsoft-hosted only (no self-host)
Limited data export options
No advanced product analytics
Data stored with Microsoft
Matomo
Open-source, full-featured analytics with strong data ownership. Self-hosted or cloud options.
Strengths
Full data control and ownership
Free open-source core (GPL license)
Excellent privacy features
Rich feature set
Self-hosting option
Weaknesses
Complex setup and maintenance
Premium features require paid add-ons
Higher infrastructure costs
Steeper learning curve
Cloud version starts at $24/mo
Key Capabilities Comparison
Data Ownership
Matomo, PostHog, Plausible
Self-hosting option with full control
Privacy Compliance
Plausible, Matomo
GDPR-ready, cookieless tracking
Product Analytics
PostHog, GA4
Funnels, cohorts, experiments
Session Recording
MS Clarity, PostHog
Full session replay capabilities
Heatmaps
MS Clarity, Matomo
Visual behavior insights
Cost Efficiency
MS Clarity, Plausible, PostHog
Free or very affordable
Enterprise Scale
GA4, Matomo
Handles high volume traffic
Simplicity
Plausible, MS Clarity
Minimal setup, easy dashboards
Feature Comparison Matrix
Raw Data Access
5
3
5
3
2
Cost & Scalability
3
4
3
4
5
Ease of Use
3
3
3
5
5
Behavioral Analytics
4
5
5
2
2
UX Insights
3
2
4
1
4 |
Rating Scale: 1 (Poor) to 5 (Excellent)
Use Case Recommendations
Blogs & Content Sites
Recommended: Plausible
Simple metrics, lightweight, privacy-friendly approach perfect for content-focused websites.
Marketing Teams
Recommended: Google Analytics 4
Ad integration, attribution modelling, and ecosystem benefits make it ideal for marketing-driven organisations.
SaaS/Product Teams
Recommended: PostHog
Feature flags, A/B testing, product analytics, and experiments all in one platform.
Enterprise with Privacy Requirements
Recommended: Matomo (Self-hosted)
Full control, GDPR compliance, and regulatory adherence for organisations with strict data requirements.
UX Optimization
Recommended: MS Clarity + Another Tool
Free heatmaps and recordings complement your primary analytics solution.
Budget Conscious
Recommended: MS Clarity + Plausible
Free UX insights combined with affordable traffic analytics provide comprehensive coverage without breaking the bank.
Decision Framework
Key Questions to Ask
Before choosing your analytics stack, consider these critical questions:
What's your primary goal? (Marketing, Product, UX, Traffic)
How important is data privacy and ownership?
What's your technical capability for setup and maintenance?
What's your budget?
Do you need raw data access?
What integrations are critical?
Quick Decision Tree
Maximum control + privacy + resources
→ Matomo (self-hosted)
Google Ads + BigQuery + Enterprise
→ GA4
Product analytics + experiments
→ PostHog
Simple + lightweight + privacy
→ Plausible
Free UX insights + behavior
→ MS Clarity
Combination Strategies by Budget
$0/month
Stack: GA4 + MS Clarity Cost: FREE What You Get: Full analytics plus UX insights (with some limitations)
$9-19/month
Stack: Plausible Cost: $9-19 What You Get: Privacy-focused metrics and behaviour tracking
$20-200/month
Stack: PostHog or Matomo (cloud) Cost: $23-200 What You Get: PostHog's generous free tier (1M events/month), providing full product analytics, or complete control with Matomo
$200+/month
Stack: PostHog/Matomo self-hosted Cost: Infrastructure costs What You Get: Unlimited everything with full data ownership
Final Recommendations by Scenario
Small Business
Plausible + MS Clarity
E-commerce
GA4 + MS Clarity
SaaS Startup
PostHog only
Enterprise
Matomo + Custom Tools
Getting Started Checklist
Ready to choose your analytics stack? Follow these steps:
✓ Consider your primary use case
✓ Evaluate technical resources
✓ Plan for scaling needs
✓ Start simple, expand as needed
Conclusion
Choosing the right web analytics tool depends on your specific needs, technical capabilities, and budget. There's no one-size-fits-all solution, but this guide should help you make an informed decision based on your priorities.
Remember that you can always start with a simple, free solution and expand your analytics stack as your needs grow. Many organisations successfully use combinations of tools to get the best of multiple platforms.
Last updated
Was this helpful?